Most investors leave a founder meeting with a gut feeling about the team that they can't quite put into words. Due diligence on leadership and culture substantiates that feeling. It gives you the data and the language to raise a concern, and to resolve it, before it makes or breaks the company.

That matters because the team is what investors bet on. In the largest survey on the question, 885 venture capitalists at 681 firms ranked the management team above product and technology when picking deals. They also put more of a deal's success or failure down to the team than to the business (Journal of Financial Economics, 2020).

While financials, legal and tech are tested line by line, the leadership team usually gets a few reference calls, a dinner or an hour in a room. That’s understandable, because leadership and culture have no ledger to check against. So we developed a method to assess leadership, management and culture with the same rigour.

What you get out of it

An assessment is only worth doing if it changes a decision. Ours gives you four things:

  1. 1

    A readiness check against the plan you're funding

    We check whether this team can deliver the growth plan you are investing in. What works at 30 people often breaks at 90. If the company plans to make that jump in eighteen months, you need to know now whether the team can carry it.

  2. 2

    A map of the blind spots, and whose they are

    Where the founders see one company and their people experience another. Think of trust in the team, the ability to delegate, and holding people to account, in words and in action. We show where each gap is, and whether it sits with the founders, the management team or the wider organisation.

  3. 3

    A priority list: act on now, or leave alone

    A concrete plan on leadership, management and culture: what to act on now, what to change or improve, and what to leave alone because it will resolve as the company grows. That way your attention and the company's effort go where they matter most.

  4. 4

    A benchmark against 500+ European scale-ups

    So you move beyond gut feeling. We assess the company on the critical components of leadership, management effectiveness and culture, and compare the scores with scale-ups at the same stage. You see straight away where the team is strong and where it falls behind on what it needs to deliver its growth targets.

How we get there

1

Nothing gets measured once

We compare how leaders see themselves with how their peers and their people see them.
  • Self vs peersEach leader rates themselves, and at least three colleagues rate them independently.

  • Leadership vs organisationWe compare what the management team believes about the company with what employees experience. The direction of the gap shows whose blind spot it is.

  • Stated vs unwrittenWe compare the values on the wall with what actually gets rewarded, avoided or punished day to day.

  • Health, culture and leadershipPsychological safety shows up in all three measures. When all three point the same way, you can rely on the finding. When they contradict each other, the company usually has a problem it hasn't named yet, and we will point it out.

Founders and leaders tend to describe the company they intend to run, which is rarely the company their people work in. That is normal, and it is strongest in the people most invested in the outcome.

Our research shows how big this gap can be. Leaders rate themselves highest on people leadership, and their peers rate them lowest on exactly those skills.

We use two research-based instruments: a 360° leadership assessment for every management team member, and an organisational health survey across the whole company. Because they overlap, we can look at the same topics from several sides.

2

Behaviour is observed, not only reported

We sit in on a regular management team meeting. What we see there often tells a different story than the interviews.

Surveys and interviews tell you what people say about how they work. To see how they actually work, we sit in on a regular management team meeting with the usual agenda. We look at who speaks and for how long, who stays quiet, and which decisions get discussed properly and which go through because everyone assumes someone else has checked.

A team around a table in conversation, one colleague listening and smiling

What you notice in a meeting depends on who is watching. Our team has led scale-ups and is trained in anthropology, sociology, psychology, executive coaching, facilitation and psychotherapy. That combination helps us separate what is happening in the room from our own reaction to it. Two of us attend every interview, so no conclusion rests on one person's reading.

3

A score means nothing without a benchmark and a plan

We compare every score with 500+ European scale-ups at the same stage, and with the company's growth plan.

A score of 6.5 out of 10 tells you nothing on its own. Compared with scale-ups at the same stage, it shows whether this team is ahead or behind. Our benchmark draws on 12 years of work, 500+ European scale-ups and more than 2,000 founders and leaders surveyed, from Series A to Series C and beyond.

We also look at where the company is going. Informal decision-making works well with 20 people. With 90 people it slows everything down, and by then nobody inside notices it anymore. Whether something is a risk depends on the growth plan.

One example from our research: 96% of the companies we studied believed their management team ran the company, and their employees said otherwise. Delegation turned out to be the strongest predictor of organisational health we found (r = 0.92), and it is exactly where most founders overestimate themselves.

With the benchmark and the growth plan side by side, we can tell you what needs action now, what will sort itself out as the company matures, and what will become a serious problem under the plan you are funding.

4

Findings are tested before they're written down

So you get an actionable plan on leadership, management and culture that the team will act on.

Before we write the plan, we present the findings to the management team in a session. We show how we got from the data to each conclusion, so the team can check our reasoning instead of accepting or rejecting it on gut feeling. It is often the first time difficult issues are said out loud.

This step decides whether anything changes afterwards. If findings land as criticism, a team will defend itself. We make sure the team recognises what we found and has the language to discuss it. The outcome is a concrete plan for leadership, management and culture that the team owns and you can follow up on.

What it involves

The full process takes 2 to 3 weeks, so it fits within a regular due diligence window. On a new deal, it can run during diligence and be paid for at close.

  1. 1

    Qualitative Inquiry

    We conduct interviews with every MT member, and with the board where useful. We sit in on an MT session, sometimes a board meeting too, to observe MT dynamics. We facilitate a roundtable with people from across the organisation, to check the survey against the team's lived experience.

    For investorsYou see how the team works day to day, beyond the pitch and the reference calls. That includes how decisions get made, how much rests on the founder, and how the MT handles disagreement.

  2. 2

    Benchmarked analysis

    Companies complete 2 assessments: a Leadership 360 and Organisational Health 360. For the Leadership 360, each leader rates themselves, and asks at least 3 fellow leaders and direct reports to rate them through a peer review. Our Organisational Health 360 is completed by the whole company, management team included. We benchmark findings against our research dataset of 500+ European scale-ups to show top strengths, risks and vulnerabilities.

    For investorsYou get data instead of gut feeling. You see how this team scores against scale-ups at the same stage, and you can use the same benchmark to compare companies across your portfolio.

  3. 3

    Half-day MT session

    We discuss all findings with the MT before any report goes out. Together, we reflect on the findings, have the critical conversations and decide on a path forward.

    For investorsWe share the findings with you and the MT together. The session tests the findings with the team and doesn't soften the conclusions. Founder and investor start from the same picture, which makes every conversation that follows easier.

  4. 4

    Prioritised plan

    We create alignment around your next steps and required action, so companies build the leadership team, culture and organisation capable to deliver on their growth targets.

    For investorsA prioritised plan for the first 12 months after closing. You can run another assessment 12 months down the line, to see whether the MT and organisation grew with the company.

For a scale-up, a full Growth Assessment takes about 2–3 weeks from kick-off to findings session. Two of us run every interview and the findings session.

Due diligence on a single deal, or across your whole portfolio? We assess both. On a new deal, the assessment can run during diligence and be paid for at close.

Book a 30-minute call to discuss the options.